Insurance, Risk Management, & Employee Benefits
Fahey-Leavitt Insurance
Insurance You Can Trust
You deserve an advisor who values relationships, integrity, and the ability to solve problems. Your total cost of risk affects your profitability. We believe that creative solutions will improve your business, and we believe that you deserve the best.
Office locations
New Martinsville, Wellsburg, Wheeling

Trusted by our local friends
-
“Anytime I have questions about my accounts the girls are so very helpful. I have had them for years.”
Eileen Ridgely
-
“From the beginning I was treated like a person and got the best price on automobile insurance. Have been with the company for around two years now. I have 2 cars and a motorcycle insured through them and never had any issues whatsoever. I plan on staying with them for life. I like them because they are in my home town and they’re good people.”
Robert Mozingo
-
“Tommy and his staff were very helpful and always got back to me very fast with any questions i had, i highly recommend Fahey-Leavitt. They are also a huge part of our community”
Jerry Ames
-
“You guys are great n always helpful when I stop in.you are great with no hassle on deer claims.ty”
Hans Fisher
-
“What great service! I appreciate the hands on customer service and vast knowledge and expertise this agency provides.”
Marvin Rannells
-
“They have been there for me for over 13 years now. Highly recommend them!!”
Karen Gallagher
-
“The insurance I have through Fahey-Leavitt has been very helpful. When I call, I always get my questions answered to my satisfaction. I appreciate their help.”
Anita Chops
-
“I have been with Fahey for ALOT of years. Every single person I have interacted with is amazing.”
Stephanie Vanderheyden
-
“Michael and his team have been nothing but a five star experience. While a lot of insurance companies feel like car salesman (or women) and you walk away not knowing if you're getting the best deal, my own personal experience (both with my personal insurance and business) is that Michael is very up front and honest...to the point he's suggested I look elsewhere prior to committing to his bid. That, in and of itself, makes me trust him. There have been times I've gone with other insurance companies due to price BUT I always come back because his knowledge and customer service is very hard to find. He's kind, to the point AND educates you when you don't understand the insurance lingo. I always check in every year to see if he can offer me the best insurance coverage AND rate and most of the time...he can find something that works for both. I know my insurance needs are in good hands and its refreshing to find a business that responds quickly and with good answers. 10/10 recommend (and I'm usually a hard person to please...go with Fahey-Leavitt).!”
Hannah Barlow
-
“Tom, Kathy and crew always deliver the BEST information and service! We are renewing again and know we are in Great Hands!”
Megin Reed
-
“Roberta is an excellent agent! She goes over and beyond to be sure your rates are the best they can be! I would recommend anyone who is at lost with their policies and rates to advise with her.”
Makayla McPherson
-
“When I relocated my business, I needed to find a new insurance company. I own a thrift/consignment store, which can be difficult to find coverage for. Fahey-Leavitt Agency came recommend from a friend. Tom and Connor came out to meet me and got me set with a great policy that saved me money in comparison to my original insurer, for the same exact coverage. I was pleasantly surprised and very thankful. I highly recommend Fahey-Leavitt Group for their prompt and professional service! Outstanding customer service, 5 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”
Kelly Renee
-
“Michael and his team are super helpful and attentive to my needs as a business owner! I’m very thankful for my working relationship with this office.”
Kasie Chastain
-
“Excellent quick service. Great years of service for our business needs.”
Jennifer McIntosh
-
“Good insurance at a fair price”
Bill Newman
-
“Satisfied customer since 2007! Very nice people to work with!”
Floyd Chaplin
-
“Very helpful and easy to work with. Take care of everything and can answer any questions that you may have.”
Mario DiBias
-
“Saved me over $500 for next yr on auto and homeowner insurance. THANK YOU!”
Herb Minch
-
“Kim Jamison always provides 5 star service. The best in the business!”
CJ McFarland
-
“Been a customer for 22 years. Always great service. Very responsive.”
Keith Hart
-
“Great service and quick responses to any questions. A+”
Doug Rutherford
-
“best insurance company I've ever dealt with!!!!”
Frank Calabrese
-
“Great people, great service.”
Steven Mitchell
-
“Is best insurance company to ever work with!”
Mark Albert
-
“They are on top of it when you need them”
Michael Murphy
-
“Very businesslike, friendly, and accommodating.”
CARLA VESSELS
-
“Everything Great and Fast Service”
Bill M
-
“I have had insurance with Mike Fahey for many years and I have to say he and his coworkers do excellent work. It is always a pleasure working with them.”
Martin Shaffer
-
“I was extremely happy with the wonderful sincere service and products offered. Roberta is a very kind and concerned agent.”
Terry Hubbard
-
“Great people everytime I have a question or concern they help me out”
Andrew Surgent
-
“Very good insurance Co. Never a problem. Had them for 20+yrs.”
Mary holpp
-
“Staff is very friendly and takes care of any issues you you should have with your policy.”
hair loft
What type of insurance do you need?
What you should know about your insurance
Thank you! Your message has been sent. We will contact you as soon as possible.
Please note: Claims and change requests cannot be completed online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.
Your browser is outdated—Please use Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge, or Mozilla Firefox for the best experience.