Adding Your New Driver to Your Existing Policy
Pros:
-
- Lower overall cost: In most cases, adding a driver is more affordable than starting a brand-new policy.
- Shared coverage benefits: Your multi-car discount may apply, and your liability limits extend to the new driver.
- Easier to manage: You only have one premium, one renewal date, and one insurer to deal with.
Cons:
-
- Premium increase likely: Expect your rate to go up—sometimes significantly—depending on your driver’s age, record (if any), and type of vehicle.
- Risk-sharing: Any accidents or violations could impact your premium directly.
Ohio-Specific Note: In Ohio, teens with a probationary license can be insured under a parent or guardian’s policy. Most insurers require you to disclose all licensed drivers in your household.
Getting a Separate Policy for Your New Driver
Pros:
-
- Keeps risk separate: If your new driver has an accident, it won’t affect your premium.
- Can help them build insurance history: This can lead to lower costs in the long run.
Cons:
-
- Generally more expensive upfront: Standalone policies for new drivers (especially teens or students) can be costly.
- Fewer discounts available: New drivers won’t have access to multi-policy or multi-vehicle discounts unless bundling with renters, etc.
Ohio-Specific Note: Ohio doesn’t mandate which option you choose, but carriers may set minimum coverage levels or conditions for standalone teen policies. Some may not even allow it unless the young driver owns the vehicle and lives separately.
Key Considerations for Ohio Families
- Vehicle ownership: If your new driver owns their car outright and it’s titled in their name, a separate policy may be required.
- Driving habits: Daily commuters and high-mileage drivers often cost more to insure.
- Location matters: Rates vary significantly across Ohio. A driver in Grove City may see different premiums than one in Zanesville or Newark.
- Student discounts: Many insurers offer discounts for students with good grades or those away at school more than 100 miles from home.
Not Sure What Makes Sense for Your Family?
Every situation is different, and what works for one family in Newark might not be ideal for someone in Bellville or Canal Winchester. Our local advisors can walk you through the options, help you compare pricing, and make sure you're getting every discount you're eligible for.
- Westerville (Polaris Parkway) Office
- Bellville Office
- Canal Winchester Office
- Grandview Office
- Grove City Office
- Newark Office
- Zanesville Office
Let us know when you're ready—we’ll make sure your new driver hits the road with confidence and the right coverage.
