Managing Risk and Controlling Costs With Insurance Audits

Written by Tony May—Co-Owner, Executive Vice President

October 1, 2025 · Personal Lines

Blog Managing Risk and Controlling Costs With Insurance Audits

Rising insurance premiums are a reality for many businesses, and reviewing your coverage isn’t just smart; it’s necessary.

Have questions?
Contact us today.

Phone: (281) 953-5200

By selecting 'Yes' you consent to receive conversational text / SMS messages from Leavitt Group Texas Select. Reply STOP to opt-out, reply HELP for support. Message and data rates apply. Messaging frequency may vary. Privacy policy

Please note: coverage cannot be bound or altered online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.

The good news? There’s a simple, built-in way to take control of your coverage and your costs: your annual insurance audit.

Whether your business is growing, changing, or just trying to keep up with inflation, your audit is a powerful opportunity to ensure that your policy reflects what’s happening in real-time.

Why Audits Matter

Insurance audits are standard for commercial insurance, especially for general liability, workers compensation, and umbrella policies. Typically conducted at the end of your policy term, an audit gives your insurance carrier updated info about things like:

  • Payroll and number of employees
  • Job descriptions and classifications
  • Annual sales or gross receipts
  • Driver lists and vehicle usage

This information helps verify that your premiums align with your actual risk exposure. An audit can go two ways: a premium refund if you’ve overpaid or an adjustment if your exposure has increased.

How to Avoid Year-End Surprises

One of the easiest ways to avoid unexpected charges at audit time is to track your changes throughout the year. If your business is growing, expanding into new service areas, or increasing payroll, don’t wait until the audit to update your policy.

Reach out to your insurance advisor as soon as you anticipate growth. Doing so allows you to:

  • Spread out any premium increase over several months
  • Stay adequately covered throughout the year
  • Prevent large lump-sum adjustments at renewal

Can I Avoid Audits?

In some cases, a non-auditable insurance program may be a better fit, especially if you’re planning significant growth and want more predictability in your premiums.

With a non-auditable policy:

  • Your risk is estimated upfront at the start of the policy period
  • Your general liability and umbrella premiums stay fixed even if your business doubles in size
  • You avoid end-of-year audits on those specific coverages

However, remember that this approach only applies to certain types of insurance. Property and equipment changes will still require endorsements, and you’ll still be charged for those adjustments.

For Example…

A client had coverage split between two carriers: one for primary and one for excess liability. Their primary policy was non-auditable, but the excess carrier performed an audit.

Because the business had grown significantly, the client owed a sizable additional premium on the excess policy, even though they thought they were fully covered under a flat-rate plan.

Keep Your Insurance Working for You

Insurance shouldn’t feel like a mystery or a moving target. With the right strategy, you can turn your audit into a tool, not just a task.

Remember that your Leavitt Group Texas Select advisor can help you:

  • Review whether your current policy is auditable or non-auditable
  • Make mid-year updates before significant changes affect your costs
  • Explore ways to smooth out premium adjustments and protect your budget

We’re here to ensure that your policy works just as hard as you do.

Have questions? Contact:

Tony May

Tony May

Co-Owner, Executive Vice President

(713) 807-8264
Book an Appointment»

As the director of commercial operations at Leavitt Group Texas Select, I’m responsible for developing our commercial insurance team and overseeing account management, support, and talent acquisition. One of the best parts of my job is helping my team reach group goals by taking an encouraging and supportive approach.

I started in the insurance industry in 1998 as a captive agent with Nationwide Insurance, where I built an agency from scratch. In 2020, I transitioned my agency to become independent, and in 2022, I joined forces with Leavitt Group Texas Select.

I graduated with a Bachelor of Business Administration from Stephen F. Austin State University and continue to educate myself in subjects relevant to my career. I’ve earned my Life Underwriter Training Council Fellow (LUTCF) designation and am a member of several professional organizations, including the Independent Insurance Agents of Houston and Texas, Professional Insurance Agents of Texas, and the Houston Builders Association.

My wife, Felecia, and I have been married for 37 years. We have two sons, Tucker and Austin, a daughter-in-law, Karly, and recently welcomed our first grandchild, Jenna Grace. I enjoy spending time with my family, especially now that our children are adults.

Outside of work, I am very involved with my church, Holy Spirit Episcopal Church, and currently serve on the Investment Committee, as well as act as a board member of the Holy Spirit Episcopal School. I have a weekend hobby farm on 10 acres in La Grange, Texas, that I love working on. It’s nice spending time outdoors, whether it's cutting down and processing trees, tending to my small garden, or working with the two steers I keep on the property. Additionally, I perform regularly as Elvis for the elderly, typically for those suffering from Alzheimer’s or dementia.

...

Read Tony's full bio

We improve our products and advertising by using Microsoft Clarity to see how you use our website. By using our site, you agree that we and Microsoft can collect and use this data. Our privacy statement has more details.