Understanding D&O Insurance: Protecting Your Leadership and Your Organization

Written by Tony May—Co-Owner, Executive Vice President

September 1, 2025 · Executive & Professional, · Commercial Lines

Blog Understanding D&O Insurance: Protecting Your Leadership and Your Organization

If you’re part of an executive team, sit on a board of directors, or help lead a nonprofit or for-profit organization, you may be more exposed to legal risk than you realize.

Have questions?
Contact us today.

Phone: (281) 953-5200

By selecting 'Yes' you consent to receive conversational text / SMS messages from Leavitt Group Texas Select. Reply STOP to opt-out, reply HELP for support. Message and data rates apply. Messaging frequency may vary. Privacy policy

Please note: coverage cannot be bound or altered online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.

Directors & Officers (D&O) liability insurance is designed to help protect your organization and your personal assets if a claim is made against you for actions taken in your leadership role. Even when your intentions are good and your actions are above board, lawsuits can (and do) happen.

What Does D&O Insurance Cover?

D&O insurance helps cover the cost of defending your organization’s directors and officers when claims related to their management decisions are made against them.

Claims like these typically include:

  • Allegations of negligence, mismanagement, or errors in judgment
  • Accusations of misleading statements or omissions
  • Legal defense costs and settlement expenses

What Does Directors & Officers Liability NOT Cover?

D&O coverage does not apply to physical injuries, intentional wrongdoing, or dishonest acts.

For organizations that also want protection from employment-related claims (like harassment or discrimination), Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) is often bundled with D&O in a management liability package.

Examples of Common D&O Claims

Unfair Competition

A business hired a new employee who encouraged former coworkers to join them before officially leaving their old job. Although the employer wasn’t involved in the recruiting, the previous employer sued for unfair business practices and trade secret violations. D&O coverage helped pay $500,000 in defense and settlement costs.

Shareholder Disputes

Shareholders of a health and wellness company sued after alleging the board made misleading statements in SEC filings. Although the company was found not guilty at trial, defense costs totaled $2.5 million—all covered under its D&O policy.

Why D&O Coverage Matters

You don’t need to be part of a large corporation to benefit from directors and officers insurance. In fact, many small businesses and nonprofits are just as vulnerable to leadership-related lawsuits and are often less prepared to absorb the costs.

Without D&O insurance:

  • Board members’ and executives’ personal assets can be at risk
  • The cost to defend a lawsuit can drain your resources—even if you’re not at fault
  • Your organization’s reputation and momentum can take a hit during a lengthy legal battle

D&O coverage helps protect your leaders and the mission you’ve worked hard to build.

Things to Know When Choosing a Policy

Not all D&O policies are created equal. There’s no “standard” version—every insurance company has its own forms, terms, and conditions. That’s why it’s essential to:

  • Review coverage options carefully
  • Compare policy language and limits
  • Ask how EPLI or other coverages can be bundled to suit your needs

Let’s Talk Through Your Options

Whether you lead a nonprofit, advise a startup, or sit on a board for a growing company, D&O insurance can give you and your fellow leaders peace of mind.

Talk with a Leavitt Group Texas Select advisor today to review your current coverage, explore your options, and ensure your leadership team is protected where it counts.

Have questions? Contact:

Tony May

Tony May

Co-Owner, Executive Vice President

(713) 807-8264
Book an Appointment»

As the director of commercial operations at Leavitt Group Texas Select, I’m responsible for developing our commercial insurance team and overseeing account management, support, and talent acquisition. One of the best parts of my job is helping my team reach group goals by taking an encouraging and supportive approach.

I started in the insurance industry in 1998 as a captive agent with Nationwide Insurance, where I built an agency from scratch. In 2020, I transitioned my agency to become independent, and in 2022, I joined forces with Leavitt Group Texas Select.

I graduated with a Bachelor of Business Administration from Stephen F. Austin State University and continue to educate myself in subjects relevant to my career. I’ve earned my Life Underwriter Training Council Fellow (LUTCF) designation and am a member of several professional organizations, including the Independent Insurance Agents of Houston and Texas, Professional Insurance Agents of Texas, and the Houston Builders Association.

My wife, Felecia, and I have been married for 37 years. We have two sons, Tucker and Austin, a daughter-in-law, Karly, and recently welcomed our first grandchild, Jenna Grace. I enjoy spending time with my family, especially now that our children are adults.

Outside of work, I am very involved with my church, Holy Spirit Episcopal Church, and currently serve on the Investment Committee, as well as act as a board member of the Holy Spirit Episcopal School. I have a weekend hobby farm on 10 acres in La Grange, Texas, that I love working on. It’s nice spending time outdoors, whether it's cutting down and processing trees, tending to my small garden, or working with the two steers I keep on the property. Additionally, I perform regularly as Elvis for the elderly, typically for those suffering from Alzheimer’s or dementia.

...

Read Tony's full bio

We improve our products and advertising by using Microsoft Clarity to see how you use our website. By using our site, you agree that we and Microsoft can collect and use this data. Our privacy statement has more details.