Skip to Content
Puffenbarger Insurance Logo
Menu
Puffenbarger Insurance Logo
  • Insurance
    • Business Services
      • Business Insurance
      • Business Owner's Insurance
      • Commercial Auto Insurance
      • Commercial Property Insurance
      • Commercial Umbrella Insurance
      • Cyber Liability Insurance
      • Executive & Professional Liability
      • General Liability
      • Professional Liability Insurance
      • Workers Compensation
    • Home, Auto, Life & More
      • Boat Insurance
      • Car Insurance
      • Classic Car Insurance
      • Flood Insurance
      • Home & Condo Insurance
      • Identity Theft Insurance
      • Law Enforcement Officer Insurance
      • Life Insurance
      • Personal Insurance
      • Personal Umbrella Coverage
      • Pet Insurance
      • Recreational Vehicle Insurance
      • Renters Insurance
    • Industries
      • Agribusiness Insurance
      • Agritourism Insurance
      • Construction Insurance
      • Farm & Ranch Program
      • Winery Insurance
  • About
    • What We Do
    • Local Trust, National Strength
    • Meet the Team
  • Client Portal
    • Billing
    • File a Claim
    • Glossary of Insurance Terms
    • Request a Quote
  • Contact
  • (540) 347-7322

Serving the Mid-Atlantic from Pennsylvania to South Carolina.

  • Home
  • Current: Contact Us

Contact Us
Culpeper, Warrenton

Call Us
(540) 347-7322 · Call
Call
Email Us
Email Us
Meet our Team
Team Members
Client Portal
Client Portal
Request a Quote
Request a Quote

Office locations

Culpeper, VA Photo

Culpeper, VA

(540) 825-4234

101 Duke St.
Ste. 112B
Culpeper, VA 22701

Office & staff details »

Warrenton, VA Photo

Warrenton, VA

(540) 347-7322

73 W Lee Hwy
Warrenton, VA 20186

Office & staff details »

Email Us

By selecting 'Yes' you consent to receive conversational text / SMS messages from Puffenbarger Insurance. Reply STOP to opt-out, reply HELP for support. Message and data rates apply. Messaging frequency may vary. Privacy policy

Please note: coverage cannot be bound or altered online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.

We Are Your Trusted Partner

Contact Us Puffenbarger Insurance

Meet the Team

  • All Staff
  • Culpeper
  • Warrenton
  • Remote
Cathy Powell

Cathy Powell

Commercial Account Manager

Diane Beecherl

Diane Beecherl

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Finn Maenza

Finn Maenza

Personal Lines CSR

Greg Burns

Greg Burns

Commercial Account Manager

Ian Fraser

Ian Fraser

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Jack Mallam

Jack Mallam

Agency Co-Owner

Jeannette Fuchs

Jeannette Fuchs

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Jhosua Cambri

Jhosua Cambri

Personal Insurance Support

Matthew Duckworth

Matthew Duckworth

Personal Insurance Advisor

Melvin Salamanca

Melvin Salamanca

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Michelle Paiva

Michelle Paiva

Commercial Insurance Account Manager

Sally Flores

Sally Flores

Commercial Insurance Service Manager

Santiago Masaya

Santiago Masaya

Customer Service Representative

Scott Puffenbarger

Scott Puffenbarger

Agency Co-Owner

Stephanie Moten

Stephanie Moten

Commercial Account Manager

Tonette Stewart

Tonette Stewart

Personal Insurance Advisor

Vicki Elmore

Vicki Elmore

VP of Business Operations

Victoria Counihan

Victoria Counihan

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Wilton Elmore

Wilton Elmore

Commercial Insurance Advisor

Melvin Salamanca

Melvin Salamanca

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Stephanie Moten

Stephanie Moten

Commercial Account Manager

Cathy Powell

Cathy Powell

Commercial Account Manager

Diane Beecherl

Diane Beecherl

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Finn Maenza

Finn Maenza

Personal Lines CSR

Greg Burns

Greg Burns

Commercial Account Manager

Ian Fraser

Ian Fraser

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Jack Mallam

Jack Mallam

Agency Co-Owner

Jeannette Fuchs

Jeannette Fuchs

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Matthew Duckworth

Matthew Duckworth

Personal Insurance Advisor

Michelle Paiva

Michelle Paiva

Commercial Insurance Account Manager

Sally Flores

Sally Flores

Commercial Insurance Service Manager

Santiago Masaya

Santiago Masaya

Customer Service Representative

Scott Puffenbarger

Scott Puffenbarger

Agency Co-Owner

Vicki Elmore

Vicki Elmore

VP of Business Operations

Victoria Counihan

Victoria Counihan

Personal Insurance Service Associate

Wilton Elmore

Wilton Elmore

Commercial Insurance Advisor

Jhosua Cambri

Jhosua Cambri

Personal Insurance Support

Michelle Paiva

Michelle Paiva

Commercial Insurance Account Manager

Tonette Stewart

Tonette Stewart

Personal Insurance Advisor

Web Accessibility

Puffenbarger Insurance Logo

Puffenbarger Insurance Services

© 2025 Leavitt Group Enterprises
Legal Information

  • Home
  • About
  • Client Portal
  • Contact
  • Businesses
  • Individuals
  • Industries

Email Us · Call: (540) 347-7322

Privacy Notice  ·  California CCPA Privacy Policy  ·  Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

Thank you! Your message has been sent. We will contact you as soon as possible.

Please note: Claims and change requests cannot be completed online. A service representative will need to contact you to finalize your request.

Your browser is outdated—Please use Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge, or Mozilla Firefox for the best experience.